A little girl

[cyngus]

im going to go against the grain and say #1 ... without a doubt..

2 reasons..
1) the stylized skin tone is a bit distracting (around her left eye... her cheeks/mouth and chin) it makes the pretty little girl look almost.. sickly
2) when you print this.. chances are the stylized look will come across to viewers as a low quality printer error. even if using a high end printer

i do however like the color treatment of the 2nd photo quite a bit.. a very muted sepia always catches my eye.. and you did it just right..

combine the 2 perhaps?

[Sideways]

I like #2. I don't know why. Maybe because the texture makes me think about older style photography which I love.